Ranked & reviewed

Best Realtors in Township Of Lake Of Bays, Ontario

Who's actually selling in Township Of Lake Of Bays right now — every qualifying agent, scored on live listings, Google reviews, and local presence. Rankings are recomputed as the market moves and can't be bought.

About our data

About our data

  • Our data comes from periodic captures of active listings — what was on the market when we looked, not a complete history. Sold and past listings aren't available to us.
  • Each listing credits the agent(s) named on it in the listing data, applied the same way for every agent.
  • We cover a defined and growing set of Canadian markets; activity outside them isn't reflected.
  • Rankings are our editorial opinion, applying stated criteria uniformly. We don't accept payment for placement and we correct verified data errors promptly — hello@realestateagentfinder.ca.

The top-ranked realtor in Township Of Lake Of Bays right now is Kayley Spalding with 66 active local listings; the median asking price here is $596,372.

Updated October 14, 2026 109 of 183 active agents ranked $722,466 top avg. listing price How we rank

Leaderboard · top five at a glance

Who are the top realtors in Township Of Lake Of Bays?

Rank Agent Reviews Local All areas Avg. price Property mix
01 Kayley Spalding — 66 109 $722,466 68% houses · 26% condos · 6% land
02 Dave Leslie 5.0 · 56 12 22 $585,666 83% houses · 8% condos · 8% land
03 Wyatt Williamson — 12 17 $608,591 58% houses · 33% condos · 8% land
04 Brandon Stapleton — 12 22 $585,666 83% houses · 8% condos · 8% land
05 Kim O'Grady 5.0 · 32 9 11 $753,333 56% houses · 33% condos

Price pockets

Where are the expensive and affordable pockets?

Most activity here sits between $79,899 and $3,899,999 — but the market splits into distinct pockets, computed from listing locations, prices and property types.

Loading the pockets…

Pockets & price heat

Tap a row below to show or hide that pocket on the map.

Area Typical price Range Condo share Listings
Huntsville Condos
Most active: Trevor Docherty (8) · Denise Penney (8) · Roger Penney (8)
$426,000 $239,000–$749,900 100% 73
Huntsville Condos
Most active: Kayley Spalding (16) · Maggie Tomlinson (4) · Andrea Cartwright (4)
$649,449 $479,000–$1,200,000 85% 72
Huntsville Houses
Most active: Denise Penney (9) · Roger Penney (9) · Kayley Spalding (9)
$1,100,000 $325,000–$3,899,999 0% 48
Huntsville Houses
Most active: Trevor Docherty (11) · Shaw Hasyj (5) · Kayley Spalding (5)
$529,899 $199,899–$1,154,999 2% 47
Detached-home pocket around $124,999 Houses
Most active: Elaine Arbuckle (19) · Victoria Islip (8) · Ashley Jeffery (4)
$124,999 $79,899–$1,200,000 2% 43
Huntsville Mixed
Most active: Kayley Spalding (17) · Maggie Tomlinson (5) · Andrea Cartwright (5)
$749,000 $499,899–$1,149,900 41% 51

This week's movers

Who's climbing this ranking?

Victoria Darling-Wadel #15 → #9
▲ 6
Kim O'Grady #9 → #5
▲ 4
Jessica Brown #19 → #15
▲ 4

Compared to 2026-W40 rankings; recalculated from live listing data.

▸How We Pick Our Top Realtors — our criteria, data sources and limits
We rank agents on their track record in this community — the listing activity we've tracked here over time — with extra weight for agents who are active right now, hold a strong Google review record, and work from an office close to the areas they serve. Recent activity is time-weighted: a listing that sells in a normal timeframe keeps its full value, while one that sits unsold for months gradually counts for less. Our data comes from periodic captures of active listings — it reflects what was on the market when we looked, not a complete history of every listing an agent has ever had. Our index covers a defined and growing set of Canadian markets, so rankings reflect activity within the coverage we've chosen rather than everything an agent may do elsewhere. We periodically update our information and last reviewed Township Of Lake Of Bays on October 6 2026.

Not every active agent is ranked: the index covers agents with recent activity in this market's typical price range. An agent whose only listings here are leases, fall outside that range, or are too old to score counts toward the market totals but doesn't appear in the rankings.

Rankings are our editorial opinion, applying the criteria above to public listing and review data. We don't accept payment for placement, and we correct verified data errors promptly — hello@realestateagentfinder.ca.

▸

Quick answers

— updated October 14, 2026 · the facts on this page, extractable
Who is the top-ranked realtor in Township Of Lake Of Bays?
Kayley Spalding currently ranks first in Township Of Lake Of Bays with 66 active local listings.
How many realtors serve Township Of Lake Of Bays?
183 agents currently have active listings in Township Of Lake Of Bays (397 listings on the market); 109 of them are ranked here — the rest have listings in this market but no recent activity in its typical price range, which is what the ranking scores.
What do homes cost in Township Of Lake Of Bays?
The median asking price is $596,372; the highest current listing is $9,900,000.
What does the Township Of Lake Of Bays market look like right now?
The median asking price is $596,372, and listings spend a median of 57 days on the market. Full market data.
Can I filter Township Of Lake Of Bays realtors by speciality or language?
Yes — this market has ranked specialist pages for condo, house, luxury, land.

The full index · in ranked order

All 109 ranked realtors in Township Of Lake Of Bays

01

Kayley Spalding

No Google reviews yet

Highly active Established track record

Kayley Spalding is a professional in the Huntsville real estate market. Kayley Spalding is a team member at the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

66 active local listings · median ask $722,466

Local listings66
Total (all areas)109
Avg. price$722,466
Houses 68% Condos 26% Land 6%
02

Dave Leslie

★ 5.0 from 56 Google reviews

Recently active Established track record

In the Huntsville area, Dave Leslie is a respected real estate professional. Dave Leslie operates out of the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

12 active local listings · median ask $585,666

Local listings12
Total (all areas)22
Avg. price$585,666
Houses 83% Condos 8% Land 8%
03

Wyatt Williamson

No Google reviews yet

Highly active

Wyatt Williamson is employed as a real estate professional in Huntsville. Wyatt Williamson is based at the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

12 active local listings · median ask $608,591

Local listings12
Total (all areas)17
Avg. price$608,591
Houses 58% Condos 33% Land 8%
04

Brandon Stapleton

No Google reviews yet

Recently active

Brandon Stapleton is a professional in the Huntsville real estate market. Brandon Stapleton is a team member at the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate office.

12 active local listings · median ask $585,666

Local listings12
Total (all areas)22
Avg. price$585,666
Houses 83% Condos 8% Land 8%
05

Kim O'Grady

★ 5.0 from 32 Google reviews

Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

In the Huntsville area, Kim O'Grady is a respected real estate professional. The Chestnut Park Real Estate Limited, Brokerage, Huntsville office is where Kim O'Grady works as a licensed Realtor.

9 active local listings · median ask $753,333

Local listings9
Total (all areas)11
Avg. price$753,333
Houses 56% Condos 33%
06

Elaine Arbuckle

No Google reviews yet

Highly active Established track record

In Baysville, Elaine Arbuckle is a successful real estate professional. Elaine Arbuckle's office is located at the Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Baysville office.

12 active local listings · median ask $529,883

Local listings12
Total (all areas)37
Avg. price$529,883
Houses 58% Condos 17% Land 25%
07

Trevor Docherty

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

Trevor Docherty is a real estate agent who works in Huntsville. Trevor Docherty is stationed as an agent at the Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc., Brokerage, Huntsville office location.

7 active local listings · median ask $490,485

Local listings7
Total (all areas)22
Avg. price$490,485
Houses 14% Condos 71% Land 14%
08

Melissa Bradbury

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Recently active

Melissa Bradbury is a skilled real estate professional who operates in Bracebridge. Melissa Bradbury works as a professional out of the Peryle Keye Real Estate, Brokerage, Bracebridge office.

8 active local listings · median ask $866,062

Local listings8
Total (all areas)23
Avg. price$866,062
Houses 88% Condos 12%
09

Victoria Darling-Wadel

★ 4.6 from 20 Google reviews

Serves the core area Recently active Established track record

Victoria Darling-Wadel works as a real estate professional in Huntsville. The Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office is Victoria Darling-Wadel's workplace.

6 active local listings · median ask $651,150

Local listings6
Total (all areas)8
Avg. price$651,150
Houses 83% Land 17%
10

Frank Leo

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Highly active

Frank Leo's office is situated within the RE/MAX West Realty Inc. office location. Their innovative approach to real estate has been a critical factor in Frank Leo's career advancement.

8 active local listings · median ask $784,250

Local listings8
Total (all areas)179
Avg. price$784,250
Houses 88% Condos 12%
11

Sabrina Baum

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

Sabrina Baum practices as a real estate professional in Dorset. Sabrina Baum works at the Forest Hill Real Estate Inc., Brokerage, Dorset office location.

8 active local listings · median ask $464,987

Local listings8
Total (all areas)10
Avg. price$464,987
Houses 62% Land 38%
12

Mike Baum

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

In Dorset, Mike Baum is a knowledgeable real estate professional. Mike Baum is a professional at the Forest Hill Real Estate Inc., Brokerage, Dorset office.

8 active local listings · median ask $464,987

Local listings8
Total (all areas)10
Avg. price$464,987
Houses 62% Land 38%
13

John Aben

No Google reviews yet

Highly active Established track record

John Aben is employed as a real estate professional in Huntsville. John Aben is a team member at the local Harvey Kalles Real Estate Ltd., Brokerage, Huntsville office.

8 active local listings · median ask $704,362

Local listings8
Total (all areas)20
Avg. price$704,362
Houses 62% Condos 25% Land 12%
14

Greg Metcalfe

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

In Dorset, Greg Metcalfe is an accomplished real estate professional. Greg Metcalfe is based at the Coldwell Banker Tall Pines Realty, Brokerage, Dorset office as a real estate professional.

8 active local listings · median ask $464,987

Local listings8
Total (all areas)10
Avg. price$464,987
Houses 62% Land 38%
15

Jessica Brown

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Recently active Established track record

Jessica Brown is employed as a real estate professional in Huntsville. Jessica Brown works out of the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

6 active local listings · median ask $651,150

Local listings6
Total (all areas)8
Avg. price$651,150
Houses 83% Land 17%
16

Sue Burke

No Google reviews yet

Highly active Established track record

Sue Burke is a real estate broker in Huntsville. Sue Burke is a team member at the local Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Huntsville -Centre Street office.

7 active local listings · median ask $750,957

Local listings7
Total (all areas)9
Avg. price$750,957
Houses 86% Condos 14%
17

Tom Harsanyi

★ 4.7 from 7 Google reviews

Recently active Established track record

Tom Harsanyi is a skilled real estate professional who operates in Huntsville P1h2a8. Tom Harsanyi works as a professional out of the Re/Max Professionals North, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

6 active local listings · median ask $571,966

Local listings6
Total (all areas)14
Avg. price$571,966
Houses 67% Land 33%
18

Mark Aben

★ 5 from 6 Google reviews

Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

Mark Aben is an experienced real estate professional serving Port Carling. Mark Aben works out of the local Harvey Kalles Real Estate Ltd., Brokerage, Port Carling, office.

7 active local listings · median ask $730,271

Local listings7
Total (all areas)19
Avg. price$730,271
Houses 57% Condos 29% Land 14%
19

Sue Morrison

★ 4.9 from 37 Google reviews

Recently active Established track record

Sue Morrison is a real estate broker in Huntsville. Sue Morrison is situated at the Re/Max Professionals North, Brokerage, Huntsville office location.

6 active local listings · median ask $622,416

Local listings6
Total (all areas)7
Avg. price$622,416
Houses 67% Condos 33%
20

Shaw Hasyj

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

Shaw Hasyj is a real estate broker in Cambridge. Shaw Hasyj works out of the local Shaw Realty Group Inc. office.

8 active local listings · median ask $579,350

Local listings8
Total (all areas)67
Avg. price$579,350
Houses 50% Land 50%
21

Janine M. Scott

No Google reviews yet

Local office Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

Janine M. Scott is an experienced real estate professional serving Dwight. Janine M. Scott works as a professional out of the RE/MAX All-Stars Realty Inc. office.

4 active local listings · median ask $608,724

Local listings4
Total (all areas)7
Avg. price$608,724
Houses 75% Land 25%
22

Darrell Williamson

No Google reviews yet

Local office Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

Darrell Williamson provides real estate services in Dwight. The RE/MAX All-Stars Realty Inc. office is where Darrell Williamson carries out their real estate work.

4 active local listings · median ask $608,724

Local listings4
Total (all areas)7
Avg. price$608,724
Houses 75% Land 25%
23

Frank Van Der Staay

★ 4.4 from 14 Google reviews

Highly active Established track record

Huntsville P1h2a8 is where Frank van der Staay conducts their real estate business. Frank van der Staay is stationed at the Re/Max Professionals North, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

8 active local listings · median ask $593,375

Local listings8
Total (all areas)21
Avg. price$593,375
Houses 50% Condos 25% Land 12%
24

Kim Gordon

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Recently active Established track record

Kim Gordon practices as a real estate professional in Huntsville. Kim Gordon is situated at the Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Huntsville -Centre Street office location.

5 active local listings · median ask $630,200

Local listings5
Total (all areas)5
Avg. price$630,200
Houses 60% Condos 20% Land 20%
25

Dan Pinckard

★ 4.9 from 13 Google reviews

Serves the core area Recently active Established track record

Dan Pinckard is a Huntsville-based real estate professional. Dan Pinckard works out of the Re/Max Professionals North, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

3 active local listings · median ask $732,933

Local listings3
Total (all areas)3
Avg. price$732,933
Houses 67% Condos 33%
26

Jamie Lockwood

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

In Huntsville, Jamie Lockwood is a successful real estate professional. The Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc., Brokerage, Huntsville office is Jamie Lockwood's workplace.

3 active local listings · median ask $692,633

Local listings3
Total (all areas)4
Avg. price$692,633
Houses 100%
27

Denise Penney

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

Denise Penney is a Huntsville-based real estate professional. Denise Penney works as a professional out of the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

8 active local listings · median ask $512,612

Local listings8
Total (all areas)11
Avg. price$512,612
Condos 100%
28

Roger Penney

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Highly active Established track record

In Huntsville, Roger Penney is an expert in real estate. Roger Penney is a team member at the local Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

8 active local listings · median ask $512,612

Local listings8
Total (all areas)11
Avg. price$512,612
Condos 100%
29

Corey Sullivan Brown

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

Corey Sullivan Brown operates as a professional in the real estate industry in Huntsville. Corey Sullivan Brown works out of the local Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Huntsville -Centre Street office.

4 active local listings · median ask $525,500

Local listings4
Total (all areas)5
Avg. price$525,500
Houses 50% Condos 25% Land 25%
30

John H. Jarvis

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

John H. Jarvis is employed as a real estate professional in Port Carling. John H. Jarvis is stationed at the Forest Hill Real Estate Inc., Brokerage, Port Carling office.

4 active local listings · median ask $1,036,625

Local listings4
Total (all areas)8
Avg. price$1,036,625
Houses 75% Condos 25%
31

Len Clarke

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

Len Clarke specializes in real estate and works in Huntsville. Len Clarke's office is located at the Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Huntsville -Centre Street office.

3 active local listings · median ask $442,333

Local listings3
Total (all areas)4
Avg. price$442,333
Houses 33% Condos 33% Land 33%
32

Cory Clarke

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

Cory Clarke practices as a real estate professional in Huntsville. Cory Clarke is situated at the Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Huntsville -Centre Street office location.

3 active local listings · median ask $442,333

Local listings3
Total (all areas)4
Avg. price$442,333
Houses 33% Condos 33% Land 33%
33

Casey Jagosky

No Google reviews yet

Recently active

Casey Jagosky is a professional who deals with real estate in Huntsville. Casey Jagosky is stationed as an agent at the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office location.

3 active local listings · median ask $732,933

Local listings3
Total (all areas)3
Avg. price$732,933
Houses 100%
34

Nancy Carr

★ 1.0 from 1 Google reviews

Recently active Established track record

Nancy Carr practices as a real estate professional in Huntsville. Nancy Carr is based at the Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Huntsville -Centre Street office as a real estate professional.

3 active local listings · median ask $516,266

Local listings3
Total (all areas)5
Avg. price$516,266
Houses 67% Condos 33%
35

Andrew Keith

No Google reviews yet

Recently active

Andrew Keith is a Bracebridge-based real estate professional. Andrew Keith is a professional at the Re/Max Professionals North, Brokerage, Bracebridge office.

3 active local listings · median ask $745,666

Local listings3
Total (all areas)11
Avg. price$745,666
Houses 100%
36

Louis Beare

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Recently active

Louis Beare is a skilled real estate professional who operates in Huntsville. Louis Beare is based at the Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate, Brokerage, Huntsville office.

3 active local listings · median ask $743,933

Local listings3
Total (all areas)3
Avg. price$743,933
Houses 67% Condos 33%
37

Dave Mcmurray

★ 4.9 from 57 Google reviews

Recently active Established track record

Dave McMurray specializes in real estate and works in Bracebridge. Dave McMurray works out of the Keller Williams Experience Realty Brokerage (Bracebridge) office.

3 active local listings · median ask $595,666

Local listings3
Total (all areas)8
Avg. price$595,666
Houses 67% Land 33%
38

Ashley Jeffery

★ 5 from 9 Google reviews

Highly active Established track record

The real estate market in Baysville has Ashley Jeffery as a professional. Ashley Jeffery is stationed at the Chestnut Park Real Estate Limited, Brokerage, Baysville office.

6 active local listings · median ask $552,766

Local listings6
Total (all areas)12
Avg. price$552,766
Houses 50% Condos 33% Land 17%
39

Peggy Hill

No Google reviews yet

Highly active

Peggy Hill is a real estate broker in 106415 & 106419|barrie. Peggy Hill works out of the RE/MAX HALLMARK Peggy Hill GROUP REALTY office.

2 active local listings · median ask $898,000

Local listings2
Total (all areas)232
Avg. price$898,000
Condos 100%
40

Curtis Goddard

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Recently active

In the 106465|bradford area, Curtis Goddard is a respected real estate professional. Curtis Goddard is stationed as an agent at the RE/MAX Hallmark Bwg Realty office location.

2 active local listings · median ask $417,450

Local listings2
Total (all areas)84
Avg. price$417,450
Condos 50%
41

Heather Scott

★ 5.0 from 38 Google reviews

Recently active Established track record

Heather Scott practices as a real estate professional in Bala. Heather Scott is a professional at the Forest Hill Real Estate Inc., Brokerage, Bala office.

2 active local listings · median ask $919,450

Local listings2
Total (all areas)8
Avg. price$919,450
Houses 100%
42

Alexis Horner

No Google reviews yet

Recently active

Alexis Horner practices as a real estate professional in Gravenhurst. Alexis Horner works as a Realtor out of the Sotheby's International Realty Canada, Brokerage, Gravenhurst office.

2 active local listings · median ask $828,999

Local listings2
Total (all areas)3
Avg. price$828,999
Houses 50% Condos 50%
43

Wendy Webb

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Recently active

Wendy Webb is employed as a real estate professional in Bracebridge. Wendy Webb works out of the Royal Lepage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty, Brokerage, Bracebridge office.

2 active local listings · median ask $662,500

Local listings2
Total (all areas)9
Avg. price$662,500
Houses 50% Condos 50%
44

Christina Clayton

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

In the Bala area, Christina Clayton is a respected real estate professional. Christina Clayton's office is situated within the Forest Hill Real Estate Inc., Brokerage, Bala office location.

2 active local listings · median ask $919,450

Local listings2
Total (all areas)8
Avg. price$919,450
Houses 100%
45

Sharon Busse

No Google reviews yet

Serves the core area Recently active

Sharon Busse is a professional in the Huntsville real estate market. Sharon Busse is a team member at the local Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc., Brokerage, Huntsville office.

2 active local listings · median ask $835,000

Local listings2
Total (all areas)4
Avg. price$835,000
Houses 50% Condos 50%
46

Karen Hanes

No Google reviews yet

Recently active Established track record

Karen Hanes practices as a real estate professional in Bracebridge. Karen Hanes is stationed as an agent at the Exp Realty, Brokerage, Bracebridge office location.

2 active local listings · median ask $389,800

Local listings2
Total (all areas)5
Avg. price$389,800
Houses 100%
47

Joanne Burlington

No Google reviews yet

Highly active

Joanne Burlington provides real estate services in Barrie. Joanne Burlington works out of the local Re/Max Hallmark Peggy Hill Group Realty Brokerage office.

2 active local listings · median ask $898,000

Local listings2
Total (all areas)13
Avg. price$898,000
Condos 100%
48

Kim Preston

★ 5.0 from 5 Google reviews

Recently active Established track record

Kim Preston is a professional who deals with real estate in Huntsville. The Re/Max Professionals North, Brokerage, Huntsville office is Kim Preston's workplace.

1 active local listing · median ask $789,000

Local listings1
Total (all areas)3
Avg. price$789,000
Houses 100%
49

Emilio Foffano

No Google reviews yet

Recently active

Emilio Foffano is a skilled real estate professional who operates in Burks Falls. Emilio Foffano is situated at the Royal LePage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty office location.

2 active local listings · median ask $506,950

Local listings2
Total (all areas)13
Avg. price$506,950
Houses 50% Land 50%
50

Alan Elbardisy

No Google reviews yet

Recently active

Alan Elbardisy provides real estate services in 106430|toronto. Alan Elbardisy is based at the local eXp Realty office.

2 active local listings · median ask $389,800

Local listings2
Total (all areas)15
Avg. price$389,800
Houses 100%

Are you one of these agents?

Claim your free profile — a Verified badge, your own bio and photo, and edits that stick.

Claim your profile

Nearby markets